Critique - Judge Colin Wheeldon (Colemist)

Thank you to the friendly committee for inviting to judge at this lovely well run show and a big thank you to the Irish Setter Club of Scotland for putting my name forward to judge our lovely breed at this show. Had some lovely quality dogs to go over, thank you to all the exhibitors for bring their lovely exhibits for me to judge

Puppy 2(1)

1st McNeil & Boyd McNeil Gwendariff Gonna Go For Gold

Stood alone but nonetheless a worthy winner. A very nice dog lots to like about him. He is handsome yet has a sweet expression with lovely dark almond shaped eyes. He stands on good strong bone with neat feet. Good angulations both fore and aft, with a gently sloping topline and used his tail well on the move certainly one happy chappie. Good depth to chest. Plenty of coat, presented in good condition. He moved well for one so young and overall presents a really lovely outline. A very promising future am sure for him. BP

Junior 1 (0)

1st McNeil & Body McNeil Gwendariff Gonna Go For Gold

Grad 5 (2)

1st Williamson Caskeys Show Stopper A nice boy with lovely shape and outline. Lovely gentle expression though still handsome and just loved his head, with nice dark eye. Good angulations both fore and aft with nice gentle slopping topline. Good tail set. Nice straight front with good depth to chest. Would like to have more body to him but am sure will come with time as he matures. Moved well.

2nd Davie Jonola Secret Love at Lochfrae

3rd Stephenson Drumwhaur Cherokee Rose

Limit 4(1)

1st Tupper & Rosie Staratlanta Elliot

Have judged this boy before and liked him then but required more weight then. Love him much more, now he has matured and developed further into one lovely handsome boy. Good shape and full of coat presented well. Lovely head with nice gentle expression though remains masculine in head. Nice clean dark eye. Good angulations front and rear. Nice straight front with good depth of chest. Lovely gentle slopping topline and moved out well covering the ground.

2nd Stephenson Drumwhaur Sunshine Girl

3rd Richardson Montgreenan Charleys Angel

Open 6 (2)

1st Sturrock SH CH Forfarian Sexy an I Kno wit JW

Have judged this boy before and liked him then. I just preferred his sister then who was more mature. Though today was his day. Lots to like about him. Lovely masculine head though not overdone in anyway. Nice dark almond shape eyes. With lovely gentle expression. Just loved his shape and size. He is well off for bone and body and in good coat. Good angulations both fore and aft. Nice depth of chest and gentle slopping topline which he kept on the moved. He has certainly developed into one lovely boy. Moved very well covering the ground with ease. .A worthy SH CH. BOB

2nd Williams Keljaru Lovely Jubbly

3rd Richardson SH CH Brabrook Flash Harry at Montgreenan SH CM

Judge Colin Wheeldon (Colemist)


Judge Colin Wheeldon (Colemist)
BOB Sturrock SH CH Forfarian Im Sexy an I Know It JW
BP Boyd-McNeil Gwendariff Gonna Go For Gold
Puppy
1st Boyd-McNeil Gwendariff Gonna Go For Gold
Junior
1st Boyd-McNeil Gwendariff Gonna Go For Gold
Graduate
1st Williamson Caskeys Show Stopper
2nd Davie Jonola Secret Love at Lochfrae
3rd Stephenson Drumwhaur Cherokee Rose
Limit
1st Tupper & Rosie Staratlanta Elliot SH CM
2nd Stephenson Drumwhaur Sunshine Girl
3rd Richardson Montgreenan Charleys Angel
Open
1st Sturrock SH CH Forfarian Im Sexy an I Know It JW
2nd Williamson Keljaru Lovely Jubbly
3rd Richardson SH CH Brabrook Flash Harry at Mongreenan SH CM
Res O'Keefe Solasdas Cooper Charms

Results kindly supplied by Colin Wheeldon and Hilda Stephenson