Critique - Fiona Coward Scholes (Judge)

I would like to thank the Society for inviting me to judge their Open Show and for their kind hospitality.  The quality of the exhibits was very good, but some of the movement was mixed perhaps due to the surface of the floor. It was a pity that some dogs did not make the best of themselves standing and played their handlers up!

PUPPY DOG

STOCKTONS RIVERBRUE ALCHEMIST AMIDST KESPAS. Well proportioned head from clean neck and sloping shoulders, deep body. Still needs to settle on the move.

DANKS-KEMISHS ALOLFRANA HOTTER THAN U’KNOW. Balanced head kindly expression clean neck.  Good front well boned. Preferred the flow of neck & shoulders of above.

JONES’ GWENDARIFF PINK FLOYD

 

VETERAN DOG

DANKS-KEMISHS SAMETSUZ ON CUE ALOLFRAN JW ShCM. Appealing head and expression, flowing neck shoulders and upper arm.  Deep body good strong muscular hindquarters and short-hocks giving him positive movement.

 

MILLANS LANDSCOT GOING FOR GOLD . Pleasing head, deep body with ribs well sprung.  Preferred the flowing outline of above.

 

AXONS BRINARA BACK IN THE RUNNING

JUNIOR DOG

ALOLFRANA HOTTER THAN U’KNOW. 2ND in PD

 

YEARLING DOG

STOCKTONS GWENDARIFF D’YA THINK I’M FAB FOR KESPAS JW.  Well defined head, clean neck with well laid back shoulder placement.  Deep well ribbed body. Muscular hindquarters and   hocks well let down providing positive hind movement.

 

UNDERGARD DOG

CHILDS’ TREDURA VAL VERDI. Balanced head with pleasing eye. Clean neck and well laid back shoulders, mature body.  Good bone and feet.  Strong hindquarters allowing him to move well.

MILLANS REDCLYST SUPER TROUPER AT LANDSCOT. Balanced head good  straight front, preferred flow of neck and shoulders and movement of above.

 

GRADUATE DOG

CHILDS’ ANLORY TAMHILL. Straight front and well boned.  Balanced body ribs well sprung.  Correct topline and tail set held on the move.  Strong well muscled quarters used to advantage when moving.

DAVIES AOIBHEANNES ROUGH JUSTICE.  Preferred the overall flow in topline of above when standing and on the move, he was giving his handler some problems today!

 

POST GRAD DOG

PRANGLES HEATHCLARE OLD GLORY JW. Proportioned head with pleasing eye. Good front shoulder angulation with straight front.  Flowing outline well held on the move.

COHENS AOIBHEANNE’S ROUGH DIAMOND WITH SHUSHANA JW. Well proportioned young dog.  Strong quarters and hocks allowing him to move soundly. Close-up to 1.

HYSLOPS GWENDARIFF JUSTIN THYME JW completed a trio of pleasing dogs.

 

LIMIT DOG

MITCHELLS SUTERESETT GO THE DISTANCE TO STAXYLL. Appealing head with kindly expression well set ears. Clean neck flowing from well placed shoulders with well angled upper arm.  Straight front well boned, proportioned body with ample heart room.  Correct topline and tailset. Strong hindquarters well muscled used to advantage on the move.  BD & BIS notes say should do well.

MUIR ROMARNE TAITTINGER JW. Not so mature as above, but a very pleasing dog to go over.  Balanced in body with strong hindquarters and let down hocks and moving soundly all-round.

AXONS BRINARA PRIVATE EYE

 

OPEN DOG

COHENS CAISPERN LORENZO WITH SHUSHANA JW ShCM. Balanced head with deep muzzle.  Strong neck with good shoulder placement, flowing topline and tailset.  Good depth of body, well ribbed and moved well from powerful hindquarters with pleasing outline.

HYSLOPS GWENDARIFF THE SPECIALIST. Again pleasing dog with long lean head, racy outline good front and back, very breed typical.

 

PUPPY BITCH

DANKS-KEMISHS ALOLFRANA HOT INSPIRATION.   Feminine head with kind expression.  Flowing neck and laid-back shoulders into correct topline.  Good straight front.  Moved soundly all-round.

MUIRS ROMARNE APRIL SHOWERS.  Another pleasing youngster to go over. Pushed winner hard.  Preferred the more positive movement of above, but two very promising puppies.

SHELDONS DELSANTO MISS DAISY

 

VETERAN BITCH

STEVENSONS LOCHLORIEN PRIME SUSPECT FOR ANDLEY JW ShCM.  Well defined head lean and long, clean neck and laid-back shoulders.  Proportioned body well ribbed.  Sound quarters used to advantage on the move.

PRANGLES HEATHCLARE BLIN- KIN MAGIC.  Straight front good feet.  Preferred the flowing outline of above.

JUNIOR BITCH

DANKS-KEMISHS RAPPATTY STARLIGHT OVER ALOLFRANA. A youngster full of quality with all the essentials. Lovely feminine head with good eye. Good reach of neck into well placed shoulders. Well proportioned body.  In lovely coat and condition moving very soundly all-round.  Res BB and only lost out on maturity today.

ALOLFRANA HOT INSPIRATION 1st in puppy.

O’CONNERS ROMARNE LADY CHATTERLEY OF CAISPERN

YEARLING BITCH

STEVENSONS LOCHLORIEN TRUE DETECTIVE IS ANDLEY. Pleasing head and expression.  Well placed shoulders, deep body, and correct topline help on the move. Strong hindquarters and hocks well let down allowing her to move soundly.

WEBBS ROMARNE LADY CHATTERLEY OF CAISPERN.  Typical of her age and needing time to mature, racy throughout with kindly expression lots to like.

LYNWOOD ISN’T SHE LOVELY

UNDERGRADUATE BITCH

RAPPATTY STARLIGHT OVER ALOLFRANA

REDESHKA SWEET GYPSY ROSE. Pleasing outline with straight front in good coat and condition she flowed standing and on the move.

LYNWOOD ISN’T SHE LOVELY

GRAD BITCH

LOCHLORIEN TRUE DETECTIVE IS ANDLEY

HYSLOPS GWENDARIFF ON A ROLLACOASTA. Moved very soundly which secured the placing, pleasing outline which she held on the move, but would prefer better pigment.

BLACKSHAWS LANSTARA SPRING STAR JW

 

POST GRAD BITCH

JONES GWENDARIFF NUTMEG. 2 lovely bitches to go over.  Good lean long head and kindly expression, good muscular neck, sloping shoulders well laid back and good upper arm.  Deep body.  Strong stifles and hocks well let down moving soundly.

TAYLORS DANAWAY GOODY TWO SHOES.  Unfortunate to come up against above. Reachy neck from well placed shoulders.  Plenty of animation on the move covering the ground but not the finish or front of 1.

HAZELBECK ADOABLE AMBER

LIMIT BITCH

DANAWAY GOODY TWO SHOES

PRANGLES HEATHCLARE QUE SERA SERA . Different type to the two above and also lost out on the move.

OPEN BITCH

STEVENSONS LOCHLORIEN SCULLY FOXES ANDLEY. Well defined head. Straight front, good feet. Clean neck leading to well placed shoulders flowing to good topline and tailset.  Strong hind quarters and let down hocks used to advantage on the move. BB

 

BRACE

Stevenson’s Brace.  Between them these girls won 3 classes.  Very much of a type, a true pair.

 

FIONA COWARD SCHOLES (judge)


Irish Setter Club of Wales Open Show 4 February 2017
Judge : Mrs F. Coward-Scholes

Best in show - Sutersett Go The Distance to Staxyll (L)
R. Best in show - Lochlorien scully Foxes Andley (R)

Best veteran- Sametsuz on cue Alolfran JW ShCM (L)
Best puppy - Riverbrue Alchemist Amidst Kespas (R)

  Olivia Danks Kemish - Judge Mrs F. Coward-Scholes,- Lyn Morris - Ken Stockton

 

Results
Puppy dog (5, 1abs)
1 Riverbrue Alchemist Amidst Kespas
2 Alolfrana Hotter Then U'Know
3 Gwendariff Pink Floyed
4 Heathclaire American Dollar
Veteran dog
(3)
1 Sametsuz On Cue Alolfrana JW ShCM
2 Landscot Going for gold
3 Brinara back in the running
Junior dog (2, 1abs)
1 Alolfrana Hotter then u'knowYearling dog (2,1abs)
1 Gwendariff do you think I'm fab for kespas JW
Undergraduate dog (2)
1 Tredura Val Verdi
2 Redclyst super trouper at landscot
Graduate dog (3,2abs)
1 Anlory tamhill
2 Aoibheannes rough justice
Post grad dog (4)
1 Heathclaire old glory JW
2 Aoibheannes rough diamond with shushana JW
3 Gwendariff Justin Thyme JW
4 Balintyne bell boy
Limit dog (9,1abs)
1 Sutersett go the distance to Staxyll
2 Romarne Taittinger JW
3 Brinara Private eye
4 Lanstara Soring moon
Open dog (3,2abs)
1 Caispern Lorenzo With Shishana JW ShCM
2 Gwendariff the Specialist

Best dog - Sutersett Go the Distance to Staxyll
R. Best Dog - Caispern Lorenzo With Shushana JW ShCM
Best Veteran dog - Sametsuz On Cue Alolfran JW ShCM
Best Puppy Dog - Riverbrue Alchemist Amidst Kespas

Puppy bitch (6)
1 Alolfrana Hot Inspiration
2 Romarne April Showers
3 Delsanto Miss Daisy
4 Heathclaire Fancy Time at Vanders
Veteran Bitch (2)
1 Lochlorien prime suspect for Andley JW ShCM
2 Heathclaire Blin-kin Magic
Junior bitch (5)
1 Rappatty Star light over Alolfrana
2 Alolfrana hot inspiration
3 Romarne lady chatterley o Caispern
4 Lynwood isn't she lovely
5 Delsanto miss Freya
Yearling bitch ( 3)
1 Lochlorien True detective is andley
2 Romarne lady chatterley of Caispern
3 Lynwood isn't she lovely
Undergraduate bitch (4, 1abs)
1 Rappatty Star light over Alolfrana
2 Redeshka sweet gypsy rose
3 Lynwood isn't she lovely
Graduate bitch (6, 3abs )
1  Lochlorien true detective is andley
2 Gwendariff on a rollacoasta
3 Lanstara Spring Star JW
Post Grad Bitch (4)
1 Gwendariff Nutmeg
2 Danaway Goody Two Shoes
3 Hazelbeck adorable amber
4 Lanstara Spring Star JW
Limit bitch (3,1abs)
1 Danaway goody two shoes
2 Heathclaire Gue sera sera
Open bitch (1)
1 Lochlorien scully foxes andley

Best bitch - Lochlorien scully foxes andley
R. Best bitch - Rappatty Star light over Alolfrana
Best veteran bitch - Lochlorien prime suspect for andley JW ShCM
Best puppy bitch - Alolfrana Hot Inspiration

Results kindly supplied by Olivia Danks-Kemish


 

X

Copyright Bardonhill

Copyright Bardonhill. All Rights Reserved.